The overflow tube isn’t the problem, so water is leaving through the bottom of the tank.
What’s actually happening
The flapper and chain โ highlighted below โ control what leaks into the bowl after a flush.
Ads
At the bottom of the tank sits the flapper, a rubber seal that lifts when you flush and drops back to close the drain. If it doesn’t seal completely, water slips into the bowl, the tank level drops, and the fill valve turns on to replace it.
A large gap means water running non-stop; a small one means the tank quietly refills every so often. Either way, the leak goes straight into the bowl, which is why you usually don’t see it.
Most of the time the cause is either the chain that lifts the flapper, which costs nothing to adjust, or a flapper that has hardened or warped with age.
Ads
Confirm it in 15 minutes (free)
Put a few drops of food coloring in the tank and don’t flush for about 15 minutes. If color shows up in the bowl, water is getting past the flapper.
1Step 1: check the chain (free)
Too tight: the flapper can’t close fully. With the flapper down, the chain should have a little slack.
Too long or tangled: it can get caught under the flapper. Shorten it by a link or two.
Quick test: press the flapper down with a stick while the water runs. If the running stops, the seal is the problem.
2Step 2: replace the flapper
If the chain is fine and water still gets past, replace the flapper. Most toilets use a 2-inch flapper and some use a 3-inch one, so measure the drain opening or check the old flapper before ordering.
If your drain opening is 2 inches
Universal 2-inch toilet flapper
Fits the most common drain size. Turn off the water and flush before swapping it; it clips onto two small pegs on the overflow tube.
Opens Amazon. Price, availability and ratings are set by Amazon and can change. As an Amazon Associate, Fix earns from qualifying purchases.
If the handle itself is the problem
Sometimes the chain and flapper are fine, but the handle sticks, feels loose or doesn’t return after a flush, holding the flapper open. Replacing the handle and its arm is a simple swap from inside the tank.
If the handle sticks or feels loose
Toilet tank lever and chain kit
Replaces the handle, arm and chain together. Check whether your handle mounts on the front, side or corner of the tank.
Written by the Fix Editorial Team ยท Based on toilet-part manufacturer guidance (Fluidmaster) and established home-maintenance and plumbing cost sources (Angi, Modernize) ยท Last updated September 27, 2026.
This content provides general household information and does not replace an in-person assessment when one is needed. Some links are Amazon affiliate links: as an Amazon Associate, Fix earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Price, availability and ratings are set by Amazon and can change at any time.