What decides it
When a new flapper or fill valve doesn’t stop the running, the leak is usually somewhere less obvious: the surface the flapper seals against, the seal of the flush valve itself, or a crack in the overflow tube.
Fluidmaster lists leaks at the flush valve gasket or its joints and cracks in the plastic overflow pipe among the causes beyond the flapper. These leaks can be slow, which is why the refills may come hours apart.
At this point there are two sensible paths: a more complete do-it-yourself repair, or a plumber. Which one fits depends on the part and on how comfortable you are taking the tank off the bowl.
What might still be leaking
- A worn or scratched flapper seat: the new flapper has nothing smooth to seal against.
- The flush valve gasket: the large seal under the tank. Replacing it means taking the tank off the bowl.
- A cracked overflow tube: water leaks into it below the water line. The tube is part of the flush valve and is replaced with it.
- A part that doesn’t match: a flapper of the wrong size, or a fill valve set to the wrong height.
Doing it yourself: the complete kit
Replacing the flush valve means turning off the water, emptying the tank, removing the tank from the bowl and replacing the gaskets. Many owners replace the fill valve, flush valve and seals in one go with a complete repair kit, so everything in the tank is new. Check the kit’s compatibility against your toilet’s brand and model first.
Calling a plumber: what it usually costs
Angi puts the average toilet repair at about $271, with most homeowners paying between $150 and $391, and running-toilet repairs specifically at about $100 to $400. Modernize puts toilet leak repairs at $150 to $500, depending on where the leak is.
- Ask whether the price covers the whole job, parts included.
- Ask whether there’s a separate service-call fee.
- Ask which part they think is leaking, and why.
- Ask what replacing the whole tank mechanism would cost, for comparison.
When replacing the toilet is worth considering
Usually only when the tank or bowl is cracked, or when the toilet is old enough that its parts are hard to find. A crack in the porcelain can’t be sealed reliably, and water keeps finding its way through.
