What’s actually happening
Water spilling into the overflow tube means the tank is filling past its normal level and the water coming in isn’t shutting off. That’s controlled by the fill valve, the tall assembly on one side of the tank, together with its float.
The float rises with the water and tells the fill valve when to stop. If the float is set too high, the valve shuts off too late and the extra water pours into the overflow tube. If the valve itself is worn, it may not shut off at all, wherever the float sits.
So the order is simple: adjust the float first, which costs nothing, and replace the fill valve only if that doesn’t work.
1Step 1: lower the water level (free)
- Find the target: the water should stop about an inch below the top of the overflow tube. Some tanks have a fill line marked inside.
- On a float cup (a small cylinder that slides up and down the fill valve), turn the adjustment screw or pinch the clip and slide it lower.
- On a float ball on an arm, turn the screw where the arm meets the valve, or gently bend the arm down.
- Flush and watch the refill. The water should now stop below the top of the tube.
If the water stops at the right level and the running ends, you’re done.
2Step 2: if it still won’t shut off, replace the fill valve
When the level is set correctly and water still flows into the tube, the fill valve isn’t closing. Universal fill valves fit most standard two-piece toilets and adjust to the tank’s height. Turn off the water, flush to empty the tank, disconnect the supply line under the tank, and swap the valve following the package instructions.
Prefer not to do it yourself?
Replacing a fill valve is one of the most common toilet repairs. Modernize puts a professional fill valve replacement at about $100 to $200 including parts and labor, and Angi puts running-toilet repairs in general at about $100 to $400.
What else can keep a toilet running after a new part, and when to call a plumber.
